Perfect roast chicken for the perfect chicken sandwich

April 18, 2018

By JeanMarie Brownson

Chicken factors into most lunches in our family. Chicken salad, cold fried chicken, chicken soup and leftover barbecued or grilled chicken. Chicken sandwiches of all manner. No wonder that I select the chicken sandwich at a recent lunch at Daily Provisions in New York. Their rotisserie chicken sandwich with bacon, avocado and green tomato wows. Thick slices of warm multigrain bread held the goodness together.

No doubt, perfectly roast chicken makes any sandwich stellar. Large shreds of moist, nicely seasoned white and dark meat add texture, richness and protein to the sandwich. When the chicken and bread are both warm, the stars align.

At home, I prefer to roast my own chicken rather than rely on supermarket rotisserie chicken (which can be dry). I time myself — from seasoning the chicken to serving, I need a little more than 1 1/4 hours. I like to roast two small chickens so there’s plenty for weekday rice bowls or speedy tacos.

I find bread to be the biggest challenge to a good grown-up homemade sandwich. Yes, presliced, supermarket bread allowed us to make hundreds of sandwiches destined for school lunches. I eat bread less frequently now, so I want the good stuff. I look for whole grain, artisan breads sold unsliced for freshness. That also allows me to warm the bread without fear of drying and to slice it as thick as I wish.

Always on the hunt for a great bakery, I stock up on bread when I find one. At Tartine in San Francisco, Hewn Bakery in Evanston, Zak the Baker in Miami, Amy’s Bread in New York City, I buy the heartiest whole grain bread they make, then wrap it well to freeze. Thawed at room temperature (still wrapped), then crisped in a hot oven or sliced and toasted on the grill, good bread motivates me to build a better sandwich.

Another way to upgrade my sandwich is to think about the bread spread. It’s easy to doctor up bottled mayonnaise with deep rich flavor by stirring in olive tapenade, curry paste or sun-dried tomato pesto. Adding something fresh, such as arugula or chopped herbs, distributes their flavor throughout each bite.

Potato chips factor into nearly every Saturday lunch for as long as I can remember. The salty, crunchy treat completes the meal. Recently, I’ve taken to putting them into my cookies — an idea from a favorite aunt. She crushed just the right amount of chips into a buttery dough.

For my Saturday cookies, I’m also adding crushed sourdough pretzels, chopped nuts and a bit of shredded coconut. Thinking of the chocolate-covered potato chips we like, I add bits of dark chocolate to the cookies as well. Using a bit of almond flour in place of some of the all-purpose flour and powdered sugar in place of granulated, gives the cookies a very fragile, short texture. Because they are so fragile, let the cookies cool most of the way on the baking sheet before transferring to the rack to completely cool. I pack them into a tin with wax paper between the layers to protect them.

Serve the sandwiches accompanied by a green salad. In this case, an updated, speedy version of broccoli salad using bottle dressing and a crunchy cap of fried onions.

Comments are closed.

Find Us


810 Dempster St. Evanston, IL 60202



Gift Cards

Looking to purchase Gift Cards from Hewn? Great! Simply click here.

Wholesale Inquiries: Email

Current Employment Opportunities:

Front Staff

Sign up for our Newsletter to receive monthly updates


Monday Closed
Tuesday – Friday 7:00am – 5:00pm
Saturday – Sunday 8:00am – 1:00pm
Please note that we are closed Christmas Day and December 26th and New Years Day and January 2nd.

Limited Supply

Hewn will close early if we sell-out of breads and pastries. Customers can reserve bread and/or pastry items by calling ahead at 847-869-HEWN(4396). We cannot accept reservations left on our answering machine.  All reserved bread must be picked up by 12 pm on Saturdays and Sundays.

Looking for a donation for your charitable event?

Download our donation-form-2018, fill it out and email it back to

Latest Hewn News


Hewn Recognized During James Beard Taste America

Chicago chefs’ menus were featured, along with continued recognition of Hewn’s role as the bread service provider and Special Thanks mention. Related


Hewn on Weekly Round Up – Chicago Events – October 23 2017

Chicago Events October 23 – October 29 Hey, Chicago and beyond! Who’s ready for a new week? I personally could use a couple more days off. I went into anti-social, hibernation mode to catch up on some very much needed sleep. I’m still fatigued but feeling much better. Can you believe all the Halloween parties […]


16 places to eat burrata in suburban Chicago

To a cheese lover, burrata is what a candy-coated truffle is to a chocolate fan. Burrata is a package of yummy goodness – a creamy cheese (stracciatella) cloaked in a gentle shell of mozzarella. The word burrata means buttery in Murgia, Italy, the tiny village where cheese artisans crafted the first burrata over 100 years […]


Lunchbreak: Moroccan eggplant sandwich

Watch Ellen King’s appearance on WGN TV’s Lunchbreak. Moroccan Eggplant Sandwich Serves 8 Ingredients: 2 ea medium eggplant, sliced lengthwise 1/4 cup olive oil 1 ea onion, small diced 1/4 cup parsley, chopped 1/4 cup chives, sliced 1 can chopped tomatoes 1 Tbs Moroccan red pepper flakes (red pepper flakes) 1/4 cup lemon juice 8 […]

Blog archive >>

Hewn on Instagram

Check out the latest Hewn News for August 2018! -

01:21 PM Aug 31

Check out the latest Hewn News for August 2018! -

07:35 PM Aug 02

An inside look at our Blonde Country #artisanbread loaf. A great option for customers looking for a lighter bread.…

11:57 AM Jul 10

Hope to see you at the @ChicagoEnviron this afternoon. We have lots of bread samples and we are located next to ou…

02:53 PM Jul 08

We are SOLD OUT of bread today...hope to see you at the @TasteOfEvanston later this afternoon!

11:10 AM Jul 08

Hewn is a proud member of: Evanston Chamber of Commerce